Comments [3] posted: Apr 21, 2007 Greg O'Byrne

I think a lot of people have seen this:

And it certainly has been written about at length, even over at oreillynet.com. So what do I have to add to the conversation. Well I'd like to talk about how this can be viewed through the lense of good user interface designs and the decisions you make when creating a new one.

Your Opinion Is Irrelevant

The young lady's opinion at the begining of the video is a perfect illustration of bias. Essentially it illustrates one of the great product management mantras, "Your opinion is interesting but irrelevent." By the end of the video clip you find out that her initial opinion was completely false.

Get the data before you make any decisions.

Morse code is a great illustration of a design choice. Here we have a method that speeds up the transmission of text across the wire (or wireless).  The choice is around user education.  Current phone texting takes virtually zero training, morse code takes more.

Even if Morse code is A LOT faster, in a cost benefit analysis it still probably makes sense to use the current standard UI.  Although it might be interesting for some phone manufacturer to try it out.  For some reason it sounds right up Blackberry's aisle to me...

Links:
Pocket Morse 1.3
Morse Coder 1.7

Update: Well hopefully the replaced video will stay live for a bit. But nevertheless I did find something else that is interesting during my search for a replacement. Check out this:

Notice the keybooad sitting next to it? It's our old friend Steampunk Keyboard Dude, better known as Jake. Check out the project page: telegraph


      Comments [3]
tags: [design | interface | pdm | product]

Saturday, April 21, 2007 9:28:37 AM UTC
Interesting. I can't see a mass adoption of Morse for cell phone but I can see a niche. Plus it would be something you would have to use on a regular basis to be proficient enough to keep using it.

Or not - I confess I don't do much texting so I'm really a poor judge of what works. I gotta admit seeing those guys transmit their message in Morse long before the fellow composed and pushed send on his phone was pretty cool.
Saturday, April 21, 2007 10:21:31 PM UTC
It appears that the video has already been pulled from YouTube. Any chance of relocating and posting it again?
Saturday, April 21, 2007 10:57:33 PM UTC
Well let's see how long that video stays up there.

And Brian, I agree the adoption of morse code will likely never grow out of a niche market but it is interesting how we think we know so much about interface designs but in fact we don't know squat.

I suggest Blackberry because they are recognized as having the best interface for handhelds (at the moment) and have the advantage of being a hardware-and-software shop much like apple in the computer space.

And maybe there is a third path that is both trivial to learn and more rapid then thumbing messages with a tiny keyboard.
Name
E-mail
(will show your gravatar icon)
Home page

Live Comment Preview

Comment (Some html is allowed: a@href@title, b, blockquote@cite, i, strike, strong, sub, u) where the @ means "attribute." For example, you can use <a href="" title=""> or <blockquote cite="Scott">.  
Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

<<< Older Stuff Yo!
The 2007 Weblog Awards




Total Posts: 446
This Year: 189
This Month: 18
This Week: 4
Comments: 201



Sign In
home | about | rss
heya punk.here is where lotsa content will be
Larry says!
Larry says!