Comments [0] posted: May 12, 2007 Greg O'Byrne

Give yourself some time to read this or even print it off.  It's a philosophical thought exercise made modern and "plausible" (ok maybe not).

Where Am I?

What if your brain could be removed safely and radio circuitry of some complexity implanted as the conduit with your body?  Where are "you"? Are you where your senses are? or where your consciousness is?

I decided that good old Yorick deserved a visit. I and my new body, whom we might as well call Fortinbras, strode into the familiar lab to another round of applause from the technicians, who were of course congratulating themselves, not me. Once more I stood before the vat and contemplated poor Yorick, and on a whim I once again cavalierly flicked off the output transmitter switch. Imagine my surprise when nothing unusual happened. No fainting spell, no nausea, no noticeable change. A technician hurried to restore the switch to ON, but still I felt nothing.

I demanded an explanation, which the project director hastened to provide. It seems that before they had even operated on the first occasion, they had constructed a computer duplicate of my brain, reproducing both the complete information-processing structure and the computational speed of my brain in a giant computer program. After the operation, but before they had dared to send me off on my mission to Oklahoma, they had run this computer system and Yorick side by side. The incoming signals from Hamlet were sent simultaneously to Yorick's transceivers and to the computer's array of inputs. And the outputs from Yorick were not only beamed back to Hamlet, my body; they were recorded and checked against the simultaneous output of the computer program, which was called “Hubert” for reasons obscure to me. Over days and even weeks, the outputs were identical and synchronous, which of course did not prove that they had succeeded in copying the brain's functional structure, but the empirical support was greatly encouraging.

A fun read.


      Comments [0]
tags: [philosophy | brain]


Name
E-mail
(will show your gravatar icon)
Home page

Live Comment Preview

Comment (Some html is allowed: a@href@title, b, blockquote@cite, i, strike, strong, sub, u) where the @ means "attribute." For example, you can use <a href="" title=""> or <blockquote cite="Scott">.  
Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

<<< Older Stuff Yo!

Go Vote for techRivet


The 2008 Weblog Awards
Just read down in the comments and click on the sign next to the techRivet entry.
The 2007 Weblog Awards



Total Posts: 529
This Year: 272
This Month: 23
This Week: 9
Comments: 212



Sign In
home | about | rss
heya punk.here is where lotsa content will be
Larry says!
Larry says!